Are HomeAdvisor & Angi Leads Worth It for Contractors? | Mohsin Shahbaz
Blog › Lead sites
Lead sitesNov 15, 2026·6 min read

Are HomeAdvisor and Angi Leads Worth It? (vs. Getting Your Own)

Share
Are HomeAdvisor and Angi Leads Worth It? (vs. Getting Your Own)
The short versionLead sites usually share each homeowner request with 3–4 contractors, so you pay to race. They still help when you're brand new or need work fast. Long-term, your own Meta ads give you leads nobody else gets.
Watch the 0:39 video version of this post.

You pay for a lead. You call within the hour. The homeowner says, "Sorry, I already booked someone."

If that sounds familiar, you're not unlucky. It's how most lead sites are built.

How shared leads work

Sites like HomeAdvisor and Angi usually send each homeowner request to several contractors at once, typically 3–4, sometimes more depending on the trade and market.1

So every lead starts a race. Whoever calls first usually gets the conversation, and you pay for the lead whether you win it or not.

Shared lead1 of 4contractors calling the same homeowner
Your own leadOnly younobody else has it
A shared lead is a race. Your own lead is a conversation.

The real cost of a shared lead

  • You pay to compete. Even a fast call can lose to someone who called 2 minutes earlier.
  • You don't control the offer. The homeowner saw a generic form, not your price, reviews or guarantee.
  • Credits take effort. Angi has a dispute process for leads that don't meet its rules, but there's no refund for a lead you simply didn't reach.1
The question isn't "how cheap is the lead?" It's "how many of these leads turn into jobs?"

Getting your own leads instead

With your own Meta (Facebook and Instagram) ads, the homeowner fills in your form. Nobody else gets that lead.

In the contractor accounts I run, quality leads from Meta ads typically cost about $30–50, depending on the trade. Here's the full breakdown by trade.

Real ad account
Meta Ads Manager · last 30 days
Meta Ads Manager showing 61 leads at $24.86 per lead
A home-service account I manage: 61 exclusive leads at $24.86 each in 30 days. Client details blurred.
Paying for shared leads right now?I'll show you what your own leads could cost in your area.
Get my free audit →

When lead sites still make sense

  • You're brand new, with no reviews or ad history yet.
  • You need work this week and can't wait for ads to warm up.
  • You're filling gaps in a slow month.

How to switch safely

📣Start smallMeta ads alongside lead sites
→
🖥️Give value firsta price-first page or form
→
⚡Instant follow-upevery lead texted in minutes
→
✂️Cut lead sitesas your own leads take over
Don't switch overnight. Let your own leads prove themselves first.

Fast follow-up matters even more with your own leads. Here's why the first callback wins.

Common questions

Are HomeAdvisor leads exclusive?

Usually not. Lead sites typically send each homeowner request to several contractors, often 3–4, so you compete with other pros for the same job.

Are Angi leads worth it for contractors?

They can help if you're brand new or need work quickly. But shared leads mean racing other contractors, so many businesses do better long-term with their own exclusive leads from Meta ads.

What's better than HomeAdvisor for getting leads?

Running your own Facebook and Instagram ads gives you leads nobody else receives. In my contractor accounts, quality leads typically cost about $30–50.

How do I stop paying for HomeAdvisor leads?

Start a small Meta ads budget alongside the lead site, follow up every lead instantly, and reduce lead-site spend as your own leads take over.

🩺How healthy are your ads?Take the free 60-second ad health check and get your score out of 100.Start →

Want me to look at your ads?

Send me your ad account or website. I'll review it personally and tell you the first 3 things I'd fix. Free, no strings attached.

Usually replies the same day · 151 client reviews

Keep reading

How Much Should a Contractor Spend on Facebook Ads?▶ 0:41 video
Ad budget6 min read

How Much Should a Contractor Spend on Facebook Ads?

Work backwards from the jobs you want. A simple formula with a worked roofing example.

Can an AI Agent Follow Up Your Leads and Book Estimates?▶ 0:38 video
AI follow-up6 min read

Can an AI Agent Follow Up Your Leads and Book Estimates?

Every lead answered in seconds, even at midnight. What AI should and shouldn’t handle.

Facebook Lead Form vs Landing Page: Which Gets Better Leads?▶ 0:41 video
Lead quality6 min read

Facebook Lead Form vs Landing Page: Which Gets Better Leads?

Cheaper leads or better leads? The trade-offs, and how to get the best of both.